Given at St. Patrick's Wareham
By Rev. Ronnie P. Floyd, STL
Near the end of World War II, two men both 47 years of age died outside the Polish village of Oświęcim. Both had been born to Catholic families, had learned their Catechism and served as Altar boys at the Holy Mass, both were meticulous souls, who labored to do their best at whatever they undertook and yet one died within the walls of the prison camp the Nazis called Aushwitz, a Martyr for Love, while the other died outside these walls, convicted of atrocities and sentenced to death for his part in the Holocaust.
What was the difference between these two men? Who were in so many ways alike? Freedom.
As we approach the celebration of our country’s birth on the fourth of July I always find myself reflecting on freedom. Freedom as it is currently understood, freedom as it was understood in 1776, but most importantly freedom as God made it to be.
You see, freedom is central to Biblical Faith! And because of this, while the Catholic Church is not, was never, and never will be a democracy—none-the-less, freedom, has always been central to our Catholic faith.
As St. Paul insists: “For freedom I have set you free.”
St. Augustine taught that freedom was the way that we were made in the image of God and that it was the means God gave man to be in the likeness of God. You see all other creatures, though they can make choices, which might in some sense seem free, are in fact slaves to their created, material nature. Slaves to a nature, which many pessimists about humanity have concluded we share: selfishness; the innate desire to survive, thrive, and propagate, what Darwin called “survival of the fittest.” Darwin was speaking of evolutionary biology, but sociologists quickly adapted this genetic theory to human behavior.
Of course we do in fact share this animalistic nature, after all we have bodies and are animals. But as Christians and Catholics WE MUST BELIEVE that we are more than our material existence—this is why Jesus says in the Gospel today: let the dead bury the dead What we call the spirit and the immortal soul, is by definition the ability to transcend and be free of the material, making material things a means to an end, stepping stones on the path to the eternal
As Aristotle notes we are not just animals, but Rational Animals Homosapien—creatures who know, and who know that we know It’s this self-knowledge and awareness, that is the basis of freedom human and divine. Man doesn’t just know stuff, he knows that he knows things and in this knowledge he is forced to confront the question: WHY?
An animal may choose to kill or not to kill, but we are able to ask ourselves, and to struggle with,
the question—Not just to kill or not to kill, but, if I kill, why do I do it, [and vice versa].
This “why question”, which adults often get tired of quickly when it is first discovered by a 2 year old, is truly the most human of questions, even if a 2 yr old lacks the capacity to answer or even understand the question
The “why question,” when we are intellectually honest, AND not distracted by the many tasks of life in the material world, ALWAYS and ultimately leads to two questions: Why do I exist rather than not? And assuming we come to the rational conclusion, that we exist for no reason other than that God created us. We must ask ourselves, or actually ask our God, Why was I created? It’s only in this context, in the context of rationality And in the light of truth, that we can be truly free.
Freedom is not just the ability to choose A or B, eandomly or based on some whim or statistical variable, as people often mean today. Rats in a maze can make these sorts of choices!
Freedom, in the biblical perspective--a perspective,we should note, that was shared by most all of the founders--is the ability to choose to be more than what we physically are, to be, as the Psalmist sings, little less than gods. Freedom is the ability to choose to be like God: to give and expect no return to love even when offended to forgive even when forgiveness is not sought and to see the goodness in all created things, even when they are corrupted by evil.
Freedom is meaningless without purpose, it necessarily degrades into anarchy and chaos or totalitarianism and dehumanization. As the famous atheist philosopher John Paul Satre, once honestly noted, without God, other people become our hell.
To be free we need not just the ability to choose, which in fact people always have whether in a democracy, the best of monarchies, or the worst dictatorship. To be free we need to have the ability to choose, and the knowledge to know what to choose, or at least where to look to find such knowledge. A free society therefore is not a society without any laws, but a society whose laws and culture promote the search for truth so that people might make truly free, informed, choices.
It is for freedom he has set us free because only free can one truly love. God created us free and sets us free once more by the example of His Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, who shows us how to transcened our material needs and live for God.
Rudolph Hoess and Raymond Kolbe, those two men who were so alike, and died such similar deaths will ever be remembered in very different ways. Hoess, the commandant of Aushwitz, will forever be held in infamy for his part in the murder of millions Kolbe, whose religious name is St. Maximillian, will forever be held in honor for giving up his life to save another. The difference between these men, their use of freedom. As Hoess notes in a final letter to his family:
During my long isolated sojourn in prison, I have had ample time and peace to reflect on my whole life…I see today very clearly what for me is very hard and bitter, that the whole ideology, and the whole world in which I believed so firmly, was resting on completely false foundation and certainly had to fall into ruins some day… Likewise did my fall from faith in God depend wholly on my false foundations? This was very difficult to overcome. Nevertheless, I have recovered my faith in God.”
True freedom is the ability to reflect on what we are and why we are what we are and having discovered a firm foundation for our actions to act in accord with our nature, to be who we were created to be: sons and daughters created in God’s image and likeness
St. Maximillian’s faith was always engaging reason allowing him to found the firm foundations need to use his freedom well.
In contrast Hoess bought into the Nazi ideology with blind faith and these false foundations led to his ruin. And let’s not fool ourselves—Hoess and so many like him didn’t choose evil overtly, he fell into evils trap, this lie, this slavery, because he used his freedom irresponsibly.
It’s in freedom and love that we are made in God’s image and likeness, pray today that each of us might take seriously the responsibility that comes with our freedom and putting it to good use.